Shield or Shackle? The Case For and Against Protecting Domestic Industries

UPI Study › Courses › Globalization and International Management › Free lessons › Lesson 7.2 Free lesson

Shield or Shackle? The Case For and Against Protecting Domestic Industries

Globalization and International Management · Chapter 7: Trade Policy, Protectionism, and Competitive AdvantageSection 7.2 · lesson 51 of 7311 min · free to watch

← Barriers at the Border: Trade Restrictions and the Question of Foreign LaborNext lesson: Sovereign Immunity in International Business: What It Means and When It Applies →

Earn 3 college credits for Globalization and International ManagementRecommended for credit by NCCRS · Business 309 · self-paced · in UPIStudy PRO, $99 a month

In this lesson

The strongest arguments for and against shielding domestic industries.

  • Explain the infant industry, national security and jobs arguments for protection
  • Describe the main arguments against protectionism, including retaliation and inefficiency
  • Calculate the cost of sheltering an infant industry and the cost per job saved
  • Separate measurable facts from value judgments in the protection debate

Free study notes

Get this lesson's notes by email

The key points and 4 practice questions with answers, in your inbox. One email, free.

One email. Unsubscribe in one click.

Transcript

Everything said in the video, section by section (1,500 words). Read along, or search it.

Opening Question

Should the Town Protect the New Bakery

Picture a small bakery, that has just opened on a busy street. A giant bakery chain already sells bread there, at a very low price.

Should the town protect the newcomer, for a while? Or let customers choose freely? People of goodwill disagree. And that is exactly the debate countries have, over trade.

This lesson sets out the strongest arguments, on each side. It runs two small calculations. And then it leaves the final weighing to you. The tools themselves, tariffs and quotas, were in lesson 7.1. Who gets organized to demand them is in lesson 7.4.

The Case For

Infant Industries and Training Wheels

Start with the case for a shield. Protectionism means using policies such as tariffs, quotas and subsidies, to shield domestic producers from foreign competition.

Supporters make three main arguments. Each one has a strong version, worth taking seriously.

The first is the infant industry idea. A new industry may start with high costs. Its workers and managers are still learning. And it has not yet reached a size, where each unit is cheap.

So the government shelters it, for a limited time. Then it withdraws the shield, once the young firm is strong enough to compete. Think of training wheels on a bike. They come off, once the rider has learned.

The idea is often traced to writers such as Alexander Hamilton, and Friedrich List. And it rests on a testable assumption: that costs will really fall. If they do, the shelter was worth it. If they never fall, the shelter just props up a weak firm, for good.

The second is national security. Some goods may be vital, in a crisis. Think of food, fuel, medicines, or defense equipment.

Security and Jobs

Insurance for Vital Goods and Towns

Supporters say a country should keep some ability to make those things at home. Even if buying abroad is cheaper, in normal times. They call it a kind of insurance. You pay a little extra every year, so you are not caught empty-handed, when supplies are cut off.

There is a fair challenge here. Which goods truly count? Nearly any industry can say that it is vital. So the list can grow, and grow. A careful listener asks for the reason behind each good on it. Fuel for an army is one thing. Fancy chocolate is quite another.

The third is jobs and communities. When foreign competition grows, the lost jobs are usually concentrated, in particular towns and trades. The gains spread thinly, across many buyers.

Supporters argue that the pain of adjusting is real, and deserves weight. That means retraining. Moving. Or lower pay. A shopper saves a little on every purchase. But a worker in a closing plant may lose a whole career.

Dumping

Selling Below Cost to Win Share

Some also argue that protection is fair, when a foreign rival sells below cost to win market share. That is called dumping. Trade rules in the WTO allow limited responses to it, in general terms. Lesson 6.6 covers those rules.

The Case Against

Higher Prices, Retaliation and Inefficiency

Next: the case against a shield. Critics have strong points too. And they start with higher prices.

A tariff on a good raises its price for everyone who buys it. That includes firms that use it as an input. A tariff on battery cells, for instance, raises the cost of every bike built with them. So a shield for one industry can be a burden for another. The bike maker never asked for the tariff. But it pays, every time it builds a bike.

Next is retaliation. When one country raises barriers, others may answer, with barriers on its exports. And firms that sell abroad can lose more than the protected firms gain.

Then comes inefficiency. A firm shielded from rivals has less pressure to cut costs, or improve quality. Why work harder, if the rivals are kept out?

Worse, a shield meant to be temporary can become permanent. The firms and workers it helps argue to keep it. And once the training wheels are on, it is hard to say: today they come off.

Weighing Both Sides

How Much, How Long and for Whom

Finally, critics point out that governments can pick the wrong industry to protect. They do not know in advance which firms will succeed. Nobody does. A shield is a bet placed with other people's money, and some bets lose.

Supporters have a reply. These costs can be limited, they say, by time limits, narrow targets, and clear exit dates. And unrestricted trade also has costs, that fall on particular people.

The evidence on specific cases is mixed. History includes protected industries that became strong. And others that stayed dependent on the shield, for decades. Neither side can say that the other has no point. So the honest question is rarely yes or no. It is usually how much, for how long, and for whom.

Calculation One

The Yearly Cost of Sheltering a Cell Maker

Last: two small calculations. Numbers cannot settle the debate. But they can show what is at stake.

The first is a bet on a young firm. Suppose a young firm in Valdora makes battery cells. Valdora is a fictional country. The world price is $80 a cell.

The firm's cost per cell falls as it learns. It is $118 in year 1. Then $100 in year 2. $88 in year 3. And $78 in year 4.

To keep it alive, Valdora sets a 50% tariff. So imports cost 80 times 1.5: $120. And buyers pay the local firm instead. They buy 10,000 cells a year.

Here is the method, in words. Each year, buyers pay the local cost, minus the world price, times the number of cells.

In year 1: 118 minus 80, times 10,000. That is $380,000.

In year 2: 100 minus 80, times 10,000. That is $200,000.

In year 3: 88 minus 80, times 10,000. That is $80,000.

Calculation Two

A Six Million Dollar Bike Tariff

In year 4, the cost is $78. That is below $80. So no shield is needed. The young firm can now beat the world price on its own. And the tariff can be lifted.

Now add up the three years. 380,000, plus 200,000, plus 80,000. That comes to $660,000.

What does it mean? Supporters call that total an investment. It pays off, if the firm keeps going without help. Critics ask whether costs will really fall as planned. The numbers cannot settle that. They only show what is being risked. That is still useful. A debate about a vague shield becomes a debate about a clear sum, over a clear number of years. And anyone can check the sum.

The second is the price of a job. Valdora puts a tariff on imported bikes, that raises the price by $120 a bike. Buyers still purchase 50,000 bikes. So they pay 50,000 times 120: $6,000,000 extra.

Cost per Job

Forty Thousand Dollars for Each Job

On the other side of the scale, the tariff protects 150 jobs, in the bike industry.

Divide one by the other. 6,000,000, over 150. That is $40,000 for each job.

Now notice what the arithmetic cannot say. It does not count the benefit to the 150 families. It does not count the cost of retraining, if the jobs vanish. Nor any gains in other industries.

That is why careful people can look at the same number, and reach different views. One sees $40,000 as a heavy price. Another sees a fair price, for stability.

The facts can be checked: what a tariff costs, and what it saves. The weight placed on them is a value judgment.

Here is a teaching case: Rafael sorts the arguments. Brightloom and Rafael are a composite case, built for teaching. Valdora's parliament is considering a tariff on imported battery cells. Rafael hears three speeches.

Common Mistake

The Debate Has No Single Right Answer

A local cell maker says it needs three years to learn the trade. A defense official says the country must keep some capacity to make cells, for emergency equipment. And a union leader says 300 jobs, in a small town, depend on the firm.

Rafael also notes two things about his own composite firm. Brightloom buys cells, and would pay more. And Ostria might respond, with a duty on bikes.

So he writes down one question for each speech. Will costs really fall? Which goods really count? And what happens to the people, if nothing is done?

Here is a common mistake: treating the debate as a quiz, with one right answer. The facts about prices and costs can be measured. How much to weigh a job saved, against a higher price, is a value judgment. And different people weigh it differently.

Try it yourself. Pick a product made near you. Write three sentences. The strongest argument for protecting it. The strongest against. And one fact you would need to check, before deciding.

Key Takeaways

Weighing the Protection Debate

Key takeaways. Protectionism shields domestic producers, with tariffs, quotas and subsidies. The case for it rests on infant industries, national security, and jobs and communities. The case against it points to higher prices, retaliation, inefficiency, and the risk of picking the wrong industry. Simple arithmetic shows what protection costs, but not what it is worth. That last step is a value judgment. Next, in lesson 7.3, sovereign immunity: what it means, and when it applies. This lesson was made by UPI Study.

About Globalization and International Management at UPI Study

Globalization and International Management (Business 309) is a self-paced online course of 73 video lessons in 9 chapters, from the global business landscape and the international manager to virtual teams, global staffing, trade, protectionism, political and economic environments, foreign investment and exchange rates. It carries a NCCRS credit recommendation for 3 semester credits.

Every lesson transcript is free on pages like this one, and the videos are free with a free UPI Study account. Enrolling adds a practice quiz after each lesson, the graded work and final exam that earn the credit, and an official transcript on completion. UPI Study has helped over 130,000 students with college credits. ACE and NCCRS have over 2,100 cooperating colleges that will consider accepting credits; the final decision is with the universities.

Compare: International Business vs Globalization and International Management

Why take it here

Why students take Globalization and International Management with UPI Study

Manage across bordersGlobalization and International Management explains how companies work across countries: global strategy, cross-cultural leadership, virtual and multicultural teams, international staffing, trade and trade policy, political and economic risk, foreign investment and currencies. It is a common course in business administration, management and international business degrees.
Credit at a fraction of the priceThe same 3 credits can cost $750 or more at a US college. Here it comes with UPIStudy PRO at $99 a month, self-paced, with every other PRO course.
Finish your degree soonerTransfer credits reduce the courses you still owe, so you can graduate earlier or lighten a heavy semester.
Strengthen an applicationA completed college-level course on an official transcript shows admissions and scholarship committees you can do the work.
Study on your own scheduleNo start dates, no deadlines. Watch the lessons, practice, and take the final when you are ready.
130,000+students helped with college creditsACE and NCCRS have over 2,100 cooperating colleges that will consider accepting credits; the final decision is with the universities.

Where the credit goes

Universities that work with NCCRS

Globalization and International Management carries a NCCRS credit recommendation. These universities work with NCCRS; some are UPI Study's signed partners. ACE and NCCRS have over 2,100 cooperating colleges that will consider accepting credits; the final decision is with the universities.

Find my college → Not listed? Ask Athena in the corner of this page, or book a 15-minute call.

FAQ

Questions students ask us

About Shield or Shackle? The Case For and Against Protecting Domestic Industries

What is the infant industry argument for protectionism?
The infant industry argument says a new industry with high early costs should be sheltered from foreign competition for a limited time, then exposed once it can compete. The idea is often traced to Alexander Hamilton and Friedrich List. It rests on a testable assumption that costs will really fall as workers and managers learn. If they never fall, the shelter simply props up a weak firm.
Why do some countries protect industries for national security?
Supporters argue a country should keep some ability to make vital goods at home, such as food, fuel, medicines or defense equipment, even if buying abroad is cheaper in normal times. They treat it as insurance against supplies being cut off in a crisis. The fair challenge is deciding which goods truly count, since nearly any industry can claim to be vital.
What are the main arguments against protectionism?
Critics point to four main problems. Tariffs raise prices for everyone who buys the good, including firms that use it as an input. Other countries may retaliate against exports. Shielded firms face less pressure to cut costs or improve quality, and temporary protection can become permanent. Governments can also pick the wrong industry to protect. Supporters reply that time limits, narrow targets and clear exit dates can limit these costs.
How do you calculate the cost per job saved by a tariff?
Divide the extra amount buyers pay because of the tariff by the number of jobs it protects. If a tariff raises bike prices by $120 and buyers still purchase 50,000 bikes, they pay $6,000,000 extra. If it protects 150 jobs, the cost is $40,000 per job. The figure leaves out benefits to families, retraining costs and effects on other industries, so weighing it is a value judgment.

About the Globalization and International Management course

How many college credits is Globalization and International Management?
Globalization and International Management (Business 309) carries a NCCRS credit recommendation for 3 semester credits. ACE and NCCRS have over 2,100 cooperating colleges that will consider accepting credits; the final decision is with the universities.
How much does Globalization and International Management cost and what is included?
Globalization and International Management comes with UPIStudy PRO: $99 a month for every PRO course, including all 73 video lessons of Globalization and International Management, a practice quiz after each, the graded work and final exam, and an official transcript when you finish.
Which universities accept UPI Study credits?
UPI Study has signed partner agreements with universities such as Thomas Edison State University, University of the People and Charter Oak State College, and works with universities such as Penn State, SNHU and SUNY. ACE and NCCRS have over 2,100 cooperating colleges that will consider accepting credits; the final decision is with the universities. Use "Find my college" on this page to check yours.
How long does Globalization and International Management take?
It is self-paced with no deadlines. The 73 lessons total about 14 hours of video; most students add reading and practice time and finish in a few weeks to a few months, on their own schedule.
How are the exams done?
Quizzes and assignments are online in the course. The final exam is taken online with proctoring; a person on the UPI Study team checks assignments, usually within two days.
How do my credits reach my college?
When the course shows 100% complete, request the official transcript from your dashboard. It is sent to the college you name, and you can send it to more than one. Check your college first with "Find my college" on this page, or ask Athena.

Ready for the full course? Earn 3 credits in Globalization and International Management.

73 video lessons, a quiz after each one, and the graded work that earns the credit. Recommended for credit by NCCRS.

Updated

Globalization and International Management
3 credits · NCCRS
Enroll →