UPI Study › Courses › Globalization and International Management › Free lessons › Lesson 7.3 Free lesson
Sovereign Immunity in International Business: What It Means and When It Applies
Globalization and International Management · Chapter 7: Trade Policy, Protectionism, and Competitive AdvantageSection 7.3 · lesson 52 of 7311 min · free to watch
Lesson complete
Earn the 3 college credits for Globalization and International Management
Enrolling adds a quiz after each lesson, the graded work and the official transcript. Recommended for credit by NCCRS.
Next lesson: Where Economics and Politics Collide: The Dual Forces Behind International Trade →← Shield or Shackle? The Case For and Against Protecting Domestic IndustriesNext lesson: Where Economics and Politics Collide: The Dual Forces Behind International Trade →
In this lesson
When a foreign state can and cannot be sued over business deals.
- Define sovereign immunity and its roots in the equality of states
- Compare the absolute and restrictive theories of sovereign immunity
- Explain the waiver and commercial-activity exceptions under the FSIA
- Identify contract protections a seller can use when the buyer is a state
Free study notes
Get this lesson's notes by email
The key points and 4 practice questions with answers, in your inbox. One email, free.
One email. Unsubscribe in one click.
Transcript
Everything said in the video, section by section (1,504 words). Read along, or search it.
Opening Question
Can You Take a King to Court
Suppose your school sells snacks at a fair. And a classmate refuses to pay. You can take it to the teacher.
Now suppose the classmate is a king, visiting from another land. Can you still take him to your teacher? An old idea says a ruler is above the courts of other countries.
Modern business needs a more careful answer. Because governments today also buy bikes. They run airlines. And they own companies. When one of them signs a deal, and then stops paying, the old idea can leave a seller with nowhere to go.
This lesson explains the idea of sovereign immunity, and when it stops applying. It is general information, not legal advice. Treaties were in lesson 6.5. Expropriation, and other government actions, are in lesson 8.4.
Definition
Equals Do Not Judge Equals
Start with two ways of seeing the idea. First, the definition. Sovereign immunity is the rule that a state cannot be brought before the courts of another country, without its agreement.
It grew from the idea that all states are equal. So one state's courts should not sit in judgment over another state. Equals do not judge equals. That is the root of it. A court is an arm of its own state. So letting it judge another state looked, for a long time, like one equal ruling over another.
The older view is the absolute theory. It says this protection covers everything a state does. Whatever the act was.
So if a foreign government breaks a contract, the other side has no right to sue, in the courts of its own country. Unless the state agrees. That view was common in earlier eras, when governments rarely traded like businesses. A seller who dealt with a foreign ruler simply had to trust that ruler to pay. If the ruler did not, the seller's own courts could do nothing.
Restrictive Theory
Public Acts Versus Commercial Acts
The newer view splits a state's acts into two groups. That is the restrictive theory.
The first group is public, or sovereign, acts. Making laws. Running armies. Conducting diplomacy. These stay protected. No foreign court will judge them.
The second group is commercial acts. Buying supplies. Selling goods. Borrowing money. These are treated like those of any business. And the protection does not apply.
Why the change? Over the twentieth century, governments took part in trade more and more. They ran shipping lines, and bought goods by the ton. It seemed unfair that a state could sign a supply deal like a company, and then hide behind its crown, when the bill came due.
So the restrictive view became widely followed. Many states and courts moved toward it, including U.S. law.
For the United States, a well-known step came in 1952. A letter from the U.S. State Department, often called the Tate Letter, marked that shift.
The FSIA
Waiver and the Commercial-Activity Exception
Next, the main U.S. law on the question. In 1976, the U.S. Congress passed the Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act. People call it the FSIA.
At its heart is one main rule. A foreign state is immune from suit in U.S. courts. But there is a list of exceptions.
Two of those exceptions matter most for business. Waiver is the first exception. That is where the state has agreed to give up its immunity. It can do so openly. Or by implication.
The second is the commercial-activity exception. A foreign state does not get immunity for claims based on its commercial activity. As long as that activity has the connection to the United States, that the law describes.
Here is a key detail. The test is the nature of the act. Not its purpose. Buying goods is commercial in nature. Even if the goods are for a public use.
Key Detail
State-Owned Firms and Collecting Judgments
Think about why. Almost everything a state buys serves some public goal. Paper for a ministry. Fuel for a city bus. If a public goal were enough, nearly every deal would be protected. And the exception would mean very little. So the law looks at what the state is actually doing. Is it acting as a ruler? Or as a customer, at the counter like anyone else?
The law also covers an "agency or instrumentality" of a state. That can include a company the state owns, under conditions in the law. So a firm owned by a government may fall under the same rules as the government itself. That matters, because much state trade runs through such companies. Railways, airlines, oil firms, and transit companies are common examples.
One more thing. Winning a case, and collecting money, are different steps. The rules about taking the property of a foreign state, to satisfy a judgment, are separate. And they are generally narrower.
Other countries have their own laws on the question. A firm should not assume the rules of the United States apply everywhere.
Lawyer's Test
Identify the Party, Then the Act
A lawyer often starts with a simple test. First: who is the other party? A foreign state, or an agency or company it owns? Second: what kind of act is it? Judge by the kind of act, not by its public goal. A public act is protected. A commercial act may be sued over. The state may also waive immunity through a written document, such as the contract itself.
Worked Example
A Transit Company Stops Paying
Last: a composite case, with numbers. Brightloom Bikes is a composite case, built for teaching. And so is its customer.
Brightloom signs a contract with Ostria City Transit, a composite company that is wholly owned by the Ostrian government. Ostria is a fictional country. The deal is to supply 400 bikes, for a public bike-share. The price is $1,100 each.
First, the full value. 400 times 1,100. That is $440,000.
Brightloom receives 30% up front. 440,000 times 0.30. That is $132,000.
Then the bikes are delivered. And the transit company stops paying the rest. 440,000, minus 132,000. That leaves $308,000 owed. For a bike maker, that is a large hole. It may be more than the profit on many other orders put together.
Applying the Rule
Customer or Ruler Decides the Answer
What can Brightloom do? Under the newer view, buying bikes is a commercial act. So the transit company is not shielded, merely because it is state owned. And not merely because its goal is public service.
Whether Brightloom can sue in a particular court depends on several things. That court's law. Where the contract says disputes go. And whether immunity was waived. Most of those answers are fixed long before any dispute begins.
Now change one fact. Suppose Ostria's government had instead banned the sale of bikes. That would be a public act. And a foreign court would normally not hear a claim over it.
The same state can do both kinds of act. And the answer changes by act. Not by who the actor is. A government that buys bikes is a customer. A government that bans them is a ruler.
Here is a teaching case: Rafael reads the fine print. Brightloom is a composite firm, and the entities are fictional. Ahead of signing, Rafael asks the lawyer three questions.
Four Questions
Signer, Waiver, Forum and Assets
One: is the transit company a separate legal entity? Or part of the government itself? Two: does the contract contain a clear waiver of immunity, for disputes about it? Three: which court, or arbitration process, will decide a dispute? And under whose law?
The answers shape the plan. Brightloom asks for a written waiver. An arbitration clause. And a deposit, paid ahead of shipping.
Pull those together, and you get four questions to settle, when the buyer is a state, or a firm it controls. Know who signs. Get a waiver in writing. Pick a court, or an arbitration process, and the law that governs. And think about assets. Winning is one step. Collecting from state property is another.
Rules differ by country. So treat this as a map of questions. Not legal advice. A local lawyer, in the buyer's country, will know how the rules work there.
Here is a common mistake: assuming that "state owned" means "always immune." Or "never immune." Neither is right. What counts is the kind of act. Whether immunity was waived. And which law applies.
Pro Tip
Write the Dispute Plan Into the Contract
Here is a pro tip. Put the dispute plan in the contract. A clear waiver, a chosen forum, and a deposit are cheap to write, at the start. And they are very costly to wish for, after a payment is missed.
Try it yourself. Sort these into public acts, or commercial acts. A ministry sets a new import rule. A state airline buys fuel. A bank owned by the state lends money to a firm. A government expels a diplomat.
Key Takeaways
Sovereign Immunity in Brief
Key takeaways. A state cannot be brought into foreign courts without its agreement. The older view protected every act, while the newer view protects only public acts. The U.S. law of 1976 makes foreign states immune, with exceptions such as waiver and commercial activity. The test is the nature of the act, not its purpose. And smart sellers write a waiver, a forum, and a deposit into the contract. Next, in lesson 7.4, who gets organized to demand protection. This lesson was made by UPI Study.
About Globalization and International Management at UPI Study
Globalization and International Management (Business 309) is a self-paced online course of 73 video lessons in 9 chapters, from the global business landscape and the international manager to virtual teams, global staffing, trade, protectionism, political and economic environments, foreign investment and exchange rates. It carries a NCCRS credit recommendation for 3 semester credits.
Every lesson transcript is free on pages like this one, and the videos are free with a free UPI Study account. Enrolling adds a practice quiz after each lesson, the graded work and final exam that earn the credit, and an official transcript on completion. UPI Study has helped over 130,000 students with college credits. ACE and NCCRS have over 2,100 cooperating colleges that will consider accepting credits; the final decision is with the universities.
Enroll now → Course details Download the syllabus All Business courses Every course with PRO →
Compare: International Business vs Globalization and International Management
Why take it here
Why students take Globalization and International Management with UPI Study
Where the credit goes
Universities that work with NCCRS
Globalization and International Management carries a NCCRS credit recommendation. These universities work with NCCRS; some are UPI Study's signed partners. ACE and NCCRS have over 2,100 cooperating colleges that will consider accepting credits; the final decision is with the universities.
Thomas Edison State UniversitySigned partner
University of the PeopleSigned partner
Charter Oak State CollegeSigned partner
Strayer UniversitySigned partner
Columbia Southern UniversitySigned partner
Indiana TechSigned partner
Penn StateWorks with NCCRS
Southern New Hampshire UniversityWorks with NCCRS
SUNYWorks with NCCRS
+many more cooperating universitiesFind my college →Find my college → Not listed? Ask Athena in the corner of this page, or book a 15-minute call.
FAQ
Questions students ask us
About Sovereign Immunity in International Business: What It Means and When It Applies
What is sovereign immunity in international business?
What is the difference between absolute and restrictive sovereign immunity?
What is the commercial activity exception under the FSIA?
Is a state-owned company immune from lawsuits?
About the Globalization and International Management course
How many college credits is Globalization and International Management?
How much does Globalization and International Management cost and what is included?
Which universities accept UPI Study credits?
How long does Globalization and International Management take?
How are the exams done?
How do my credits reach my college?
Ready for the full course? Earn 3 credits in Globalization and International Management.
73 video lessons, a quiz after each one, and the graded work that earns the credit. Recommended for credit by NCCRS.
UPIStudy PRO · $99 a month
Get college credit for Globalization and International Management for $99?
Take Globalization and International Management and every other PRO course for $99/month with UPIStudy PRO. Globalization and International Management carries an NCCRS credit recommendation; universities may consider it.
Or start PRO now · $99/month →The credit comes from finishing the full course and its proctored final exam. Your college decides what it accepts.
Updated
3 credits · NCCRSEnroll →