UPI Study › Courses › Human Resources Management › Free lessons › Lesson 10.6 Free with a free account
Closed Shops vs. Open Shops: What They Mean for HR
Human Resources Management · Chapter 10: Working With Unions: Collective Bargaining and Labor RelationsSection 10.6 · lesson 76 of 9116 min · free with a free account
Free preview
Create a free account to keep watching
It takes a minute and costs nothing. Your free account unlocks all of Chapter 1 and 3 more lessons of Human Resources Management.
Lesson complete
Earn the 3 college credits for Human Resources Management
Enrolling adds a quiz after each lesson, the graded work and the official transcript. Recommended for credit by NCCRS.
Next lesson: How Unions Get Started and How They Can Be Dissolved →← What Union Members and Union Leaders Actually DoNext lesson: How Unions Get Started and How They Can Be Dissolved →
In this lesson
Union security, voluntary membership, lawful payments, and payroll authorization.
- Distinguish 5 conventional arrangements and their actual legal limits.
- Compare right-to-work rules, public-sector consent and private-sector objections.
- Administer authorization, deductions, remittance, reconciliation and revocation.
Free study notes
Get this lesson's notes by email
The key points and 4 practice questions with answers, in your inbox. One email, free.
One email. Unsubscribe in one click.
Transcript
Everything said in the video, section by section (1,939 words). Read along, or search it.
Working With Unions: Collective Bargaining and Labor Relations
Closed Shops vs. Open Shops: What They Mean for HR
Union security describes any agreement obligation, that represented employees owe to the union. The conventional labels include closed, union, agency, maintenance, and open shop arrangements. Their literal definitions cannot be applied, without checking federal coverage, sector, and state law. The closed shop is prohibited under the NLRA, while permitted security obligations have important financial limits. Full union membership is optional, and must be distinguished from any lawful required financial support. A third issue is payroll authorization, which determines permission to deduct rather than membership itself. State right-to-work rules can prohibit compulsory support, while voluntary support remains possible. Public-sector fees from nonconsenting employees are constitutionally barred, regardless of a state’s private-sector rule. Private-sector objectors have different rights, limiting required contributions to permitted representation functions. Payroll must verify consent, amounts, remittance, reconciliation, and lawful revocation before making changes. Our goal is precise administration, with the actual document read alongside its legal limits.
5 CONVENTIONAL ARRANGEMENTS
Read the Legal Limit Before Applying the Label
The closed shop requires union membership before hiring, and is prohibited under the NLRA. The union shop conventionally describes joining after hire, generally after the statutory thirty-day period. But its lawful employment obligation is financial, rather than compulsory full membership and political participation. Special rules can alter timing, including the construction industry, so check actual coverage. The agency shop conventionally requires a fee, without full membership, where applicable law permits it. State prohibitions and public-sector consent rules can prevent, that compulsory fee from being enforced. Maintenance of membership describes joiners remaining for a term, but literal resignation restrictions need correction. Under the NLRA, unions cannot restrict a member’s freedom to resign from membership. Any continuing financial obligation requires its own lawful basis, rather than a ban on leaving. The open shop requires neither membership nor payment, so union income relies on voluntary support. An open shop can still have a union agreement, and an exclusive representative covering the entire unit.
3 DIFFERENT RELATIONSHIPS
Membership, Financial Support and Payroll Deduction Are Separate
Full membership is the employee’s organizational relationship, with applicable participation under union governance rules. Where the NLRA applies, an employee retains the right to resign that membership. A lawful security provision can impose permitted financial obligations, without forcing full organizational membership. Those obligations have statutory limits, and any applicable rights to object to nonrepresentational expenditures. Checkoff is different again: employee permission for the employer to deduct from payroll. Its actual wording and governing law determine, its scope, lawful duration, and revocation rules. Resigning membership does not automatically answer, every separate payment obligation or deduction-authorization question. Likewise, stopping a deduction does not necessarily eliminate, an independently lawful obligation to pay. Do not require political participation or full membership, as an NLRA employment condition. Do not assume a signature on one document, supplies authority for every union-related action. Read the specific promise, identify the relationship it governs, and apply its actual legal limits.
RIGHT-TO-WORK LAWS
State Rules Can Prohibit Compulsory Financial Support
Section fourteen, subsection b, allows state restrictions on union-security agreements under the federal framework. An applicable right-to-work law can prohibit, membership or fee payment as a condition of employment. Voluntary membership and contributions remain possible, alongside an otherwise lawful collective agreement. The exclusive representative still covers the unit, under the governing framework, including nonmembers. Right-to-work therefore does not mean every employee becomes unrepresented, or the union disappears. Nor does its name create a general entitlement, to be hired or retain any job. Check current state law and actual work location, rather than memorize a frozen state count. The position has changed in both directions, and administrative rules require current jurisdictional review. Federal coverage and sector matter too; rail, air, and public-sector systems require their own analysis. A national agreement may therefore require different administration, across sites governed by different lawful limits. Membership density affects funding, rather than automatically changing which unit employees receive exclusive representation.
POLICY AND EVIDENCE
State Both Positions and Identify the Shared Funding Structure
Supporters emphasize an individual’s freedom, not to fund an organization as the price of keeping a job. They also argue that voluntary support encourages unions, to demonstrate value and remain responsive. Opponents emphasize representation duties and negotiated benefits, that extend to workers who do not pay. They argue that compulsory-support restrictions can weaken unions, and shift representation costs onto contributors. The shared analytical structure is a collective funding problem, under exclusive representation of the unit. An individual can receive negotiated terms, while hoping enough other people finance their production and administration. One response favors lawful shared fees, while another challenges the exclusive-representation arrangement that produces this incentive. Neither description requires us to assume, that every nonpayer has exactly the same motives. Effects on density, wages, jobs, and firm location are empirical questions, requiring evidence and careful comparisons. States differ in many other ways, making simple observed comparisons an uncertain basis for causal claims. Evidence alone cannot decide how competing freedoms and funding obligations should be valued; distinguish that normative choice.
PUBLIC-SECTOR NONCONSENTING EMPLOYEES
Janus Bars Compelled Agency Fees Across States
In twenty eighteen, Janus overruled Abood, concerning agency fees from nonconsenting public-sector employees. Compelling those fees violates the First Amendment, even where a state had previously authorized them. Covered union payments cannot be collected, without the employee’s affirmative consent to pay. The practical funding change pushed affected unions, toward voluntary rather than compulsory financial support. Preserve the applicable evidence of consent, and follow the actual governing public-sector rules. This does not mean every payroll cycle requires, a newly signed membership or deduction document. Lawful voluntary agreements by consenting members remain distinct, from fees imposed on nonconsenting workers. Janus does not automatically give those members permission, to disregard every voluntary contractual promise. Likewise, a membership resignation does not automatically resolve, all separate deduction and payment commitments. State and sector rules, authorization wording, and controlling decisions determine the particular administrative response. The nationwide compulsory-fee restriction is clear, while public-sector bargaining and administration still require jurisdictional detail.
PRIVATE-SECTOR OBJECTORS
Beck Limits Required Payments to Permitted Representation Costs
Private-sector objection rights apply differently, where the NLRA permits a lawful security obligation. A nonmember may object to required funding, beyond permitted representation-related functions under Beck. Those functions include collective bargaining, contract administration, and the handling of contractual grievances. Required objector payments exclude unrelated political or ideological activity, rather than funding every union expenditure. The union must give required rights notice, and follow lawful calculation, explanation, and challenge procedures. An objector remains protected by the contract, without choosing full organizational membership. Where compulsory support is prohibited, objection doctrine does not create, permission to require a fee anyway. The payroll team should verify authorized instructions, rather than invent a reduced percentage from a summary. Seek advice when the amount or chargeability is disputed, and preserve accurate records of the response. Lawful security-clause enforcement has further notice and opportunity requirements, before any discharge request can be acted upon. A union’s request alone therefore does not justify immediate dismissal; examine every applicable condition first.
DUES CHECKOFF PROCESS
Authorize, Verify, Deduct, Remit and Reconcile
Begin with the employee’s actual authorization, verifying lawful consent, coverage, scope, and effective dates. Next, match the applicable agreement and authorization, against a verified notice of the lawful rate. An email supplies information to check, rather than automatic authority for any proposed deduction. Resolve differences and assign an owner, so a legitimate change does not disappear into a general inbox. Payroll then deducts the lawful authorized amount, with a record identifying the employee and cycle. Remittance transfers the correct funds and supporting detail, on the agreed lawful schedule. Reconciliation compares authorizations, applicable rates, payroll deductions, and the amounts actually remitted. That comparison can expose missing transfers, obsolete rates, excessive deductions, or deductions without permission. Revocation and other changes follow the actual lawful terms, with unresolved questions referred appropriately. Keep exception tracking and evidence of action, rather than merely retain a copy of each email. Accurate administration requires the whole chain, not an assumption that repeated monthly processing proves everything correct.
REVOCATION AND ADMINISTRATIVE CONTROL
Read the Authorization Alongside Its Statutory Limits
Authorization must satisfy the applicable sector and wage-deduction requirements, rather than merely exist in a file. Its lawful scope matters, when determining amounts, changes, and any relevant objector treatment. Remittance records should show both the payment, and how it reconciles to underlying employee deductions. A revocation request requires the wording, valid window, delivery rules, and any overriding law to be checked. For private-sector checkoff, the LMRA limits how long an authorization may be irrevocable. It cannot be irrevocable beyond one year, or agreement termination, whichever occurs sooner. Do not assume a printed annual restriction, can remove those statutory revocation rights. Likewise, contract expiration alone does not settle, every question about an ongoing employer deduction duty. Membership resignation, checkoff revocation, and payment obligations must still be analyzed separately. Explain verified terms accurately, and refer a genuine legal dispute rather than fabricate an administrative conclusion. Prompt handling means checking and communicating, not automatically stopping or reflexively refusing whatever an employee requests.
FICTIONAL HARLOW MUTUAL CASE
Responsiveness Failed When Payroll Changed a Deduction First
At fictional Harlow Mutual, an employee emails payroll, asking that dues deductions stop immediately. The administrator stops the next cycle, trying to respond helpfully without first checking the document. The source authorization provides a fifteen-day annual window, which closed two months earlier. Before enforcing that restriction, verify its legality, and whether another revocation right applies. If it is enforceable and no other right applies, stopping outside the window was incorrect administration. The union expects accurate application, while the employee now expects the promised payroll change to continue. Resuming deductions without a clear explanation, makes the employer’s original responsiveness look like an unexplained reversal. Harlow routes requests to one named owner, who checks the authorization and governing law before changes. The response records the request, explains verified terms, and identifies when lawful revocation is available. Where the position is uncertain, referral is part of the process, rather than permission for guessing. The broader lesson is practical: read the controlling document, alongside its legal limits, before committing the employer.
8 CLAUSE CLASSIFICATIONS
Identify the Arrangement and Then Test the Actual Condition
Clause one, joining within thirty days, is conventionally a union shop, subject to the financial-membership distinction. Clause four, hiring only existing members, describes a prohibited closed shop under the NLRA. Clause two, keeping joiners through expiration, is conventionally maintenance of membership, but cannot override resignation rights. Clause six, allowing resignation only annually, is an unlawful NLRA membership restriction rather than a valid checkoff assumption. Clause three, paying a fee without joining, is agency shop language, requiring actual security and consent analysis. Clause five, voluntary joining and payment, is an open shop, which can still have exclusive representation. Clause seven, deduction for employees who authorized it, describes checkoff rather than a security arrangement itself. Its permission, amount, and revocation must satisfy the applicable document, and actual legal limits. Clause eight, job-conditioned payment in a banning state, cannot defeat an applicable prohibition through national agreement wording. These eight classifications identify the concepts, while legal assessment determines whether a particular condition can operate. Especially distinguish annual membership restrictions, from separately analyzed deduction windows; similar timing language can govern different relationships.
4 SETTINGS AND REVERSE PROBLEM
Match the Jurisdiction, Then Trace the Payroll Failure
A private manufacturer without an applicable state ban, may negotiate lawful security within the federal limits. A private retailer under an applicable ban cannot impose required membership or fees, as employment conditions. A municipal employer cannot collect compelled fees from nonconsenting employees, regardless of its state’s private-sector position. A private employer with sites in both settings needs lawful differentiated administration, under actual coverage and location rules. The reverse case involves four months of insufficient remittance, and two years without reconciliation. A rate increase reached a general HR address, but nobody verified it against the agreement. The old deduction continued, so the notification and rate-verification stage failed to trigger correct action. Reconciliation of authorized rates, deductions, and remittances would have exposed the discrepancy, before it accumulated further. Quantify the error and correct it lawfully; do not assume any shortfall authorizes unsupported deductions from future pay. Define all five arrangements, security, right-to-work, and checkoff, with membership, payment, and authorization kept distinct. Next, we examine organizing and decertification: how representation begins, how it ends, and each party’s obligations.
About Human Resources Management at UPI Study
Human Resources Management (Business 306) is a self-paced online course of 91 video lessons in 12 chapters, from what HR does and how jobs are designed to hiring, training, performance reviews, pay and benefits, safety, employment law, unions, global staffing and remote work. It carries a NCCRS credit recommendation for 3 semester credits.
Every lesson transcript is free on pages like this one, and the videos are free with a free UPI Study account. Enrolling adds a practice quiz after each lesson, the graded work and final exam that earn the credit, lifetime access, and an official transcript on completion. UPI Study has helped over 130,000 students with college credits. ACE and NCCRS have over 2,100 cooperating colleges that will consider accepting credits; the final decision is with the universities.
Enroll now → Course details Download the syllabus All Business courses
Why take it here
Why students take Human Resources Management with UPI Study
Where the credit goes
Universities that work with NCCRS
Human Resources Management carries a NCCRS credit recommendation. These universities work with NCCRS; some are UPI Study's signed partners. ACE and NCCRS have over 2,100 cooperating colleges that will consider accepting credits; the final decision is with the universities.
Thomas Edison State UniversitySigned partner
University of the PeopleSigned partner
Charter Oak State CollegeSigned partner
Strayer UniversitySigned partner
Columbia Southern UniversitySigned partner
Indiana TechSigned partner
Penn StateWorks with NCCRS
Southern New Hampshire UniversityWorks with NCCRS
SUNYWorks with NCCRS
+many more cooperating universitiesFind my college →Find my college → Not listed? Ask Athena in the corner of this page, or book a 15-minute call.
FAQ
Questions students ask us
About Closed Shops vs. Open Shops: What They Mean for HR
What is the difference between a closed shop and an open shop?
What is the difference between a union shop and an agency shop?
What is a right-to-work law?
What did the Supreme Court decide in Janus v. AFSCME?
About the Human Resources Management course
How many college credits is Human Resources Management?
How much does Human Resources Management cost and what is included?
Which universities accept UPI Study credits?
How long does Human Resources Management take?
How are the exams done?
How do my credits reach my college?
Ready for the full course? Earn 3 credits in Human Resources Management.
91 video lessons, a quiz after each one, and the graded work that earns the credit. Recommended for credit by NCCRS.
3 credits · NCCRSEnroll →