UPI Study › Courses › Psychology of Personality › Free lessons › Lesson 12.3 Free with a free account

Critiques of Humanistic Psychology: Limitations and Counterarguments

Psychology of Personality · Chapter 12: Humanistic Psychology: Applications and CritiquesSection 12.3 · lesson 74 of 83video coming soon

← The Five-Factor Model of Dispositional Traits: Overview and Relevance Next lesson: Humanistic Psychology in Contemporary Therapeutic Practice →

Earn 3 college credits for Psychology of PersonalityRecommended for credit by NCCRS · Psychology 300 · self-paced · one payment, lifetime access

Enroll in Psychology of Personality · $250 →Download the syllabus (PDF)

In this lesson

Four serious charges, and the defence that actually answers one of them.

State the main empirical critique
Explain the charge of excessive optimism
Describe the cultural narrowness objection
Weigh the counterarguments defenders offer

Free study notes

Get this lesson's notes by email

The key points and 4 practice questions with answers, in your inbox. One email, free.

One email. Unsubscribe in one click.

Transcript

Everything said in the video, section by section (844 words). Read along, or search it.

Humanistic Psychology: Applications and Critiques

Critiques of Humanistic Psychology and the Counterarguments

Humanistic psychology faces four serious criticisms. Its defenders have an answer to each of them. But the answers are not equally strong, and that is the interesting part. Three of them argue about what psychology should value. One of them produces evidence. This section works through both sides. And asks which parts of the defence actually hold.

The Main Charge

Limited Empirical Rigour

The approach has been praised for restoring attention to the whole person. It also faces serious critiques. The most common one is methodological. Concepts such as self-actualization are difficult to define precisely. So is the fully functioning person. And both are difficult to measure objectively. Which makes systematic testing challenging. The technical name for the missing step is operationalization. That means defining a concept in measurable terms. Until that is done, there is nothing for evidence to bear on.

Second Charge

Overly Optimistic About Human Nature

The second charge is about the approach's view of human nature. Critics say it is overly optimistic. And they name three things it pays too little attention to. Destructive behaviour. Situational pressures. And unconscious processes. This is not a complaint about tone, or about being too cheerful. Each of those three is a well-studied source of human behaviour. A model that underweights them will systematically mispredict. And it will mispredict precisely in the situations where they dominate.

Third Charge

Cultural Values Presented as Universal Truths

The third charge concerns culture. The approach places strong emphasis on individual growth, and self-direction. Critics describe that as reflecting particular cultural values. Rather than universal truths about personality. The force of the objection is about status, not about content. It does not claim self-direction is unimportant. It claims a culturally located ideal has been presented as a finding about human nature. Those are very different things to assert.

The Trade-Off

Where the Approach Actually Sits

It helps to see the trade-off spatially. Humanistic theory scores high on attention to meaning, and to the whole person. And it scores lower on empirical testability. The Five-Factor Model, covered in the previous section, trades the opposite way. Strong on measurement. Much narrower in what it attempts to describe. Neither position is simply better than the other. But knowing where a theory sits tells you what to ask of it.

Defence One

Hard to Measure Is Not the Same as Unimportant

Defenders of humanistic psychology offer several responses. The first concerns what measurement difficulty actually establishes. They argue that the difficulty of measuring subjective experience does not make it unimportant. And that strictly objective methods can miss something. Precisely what matters most about being human. On this account, the approach deliberately values depth and meaning. Over narrow quantification. So the trade was made knowingly. It was not an oversight.

Assess It

How Far That Defence Goes

Take that first counterargument seriously. And take it precisely. What it establishes is real. Importance and measurability are different properties. A hard-to-measure thing can still matter enormously. But notice what it leaves entirely open. Whether the specific claims are true. Saying that a topic matters is not evidence about any particular assertion regarding it. Which is why the second defence carries more weight. It does not argue about what evidence is for. It produces some.

Defence Two

The Concrete Contributions

Supporters point to two concrete contributions. The first is client-centered therapy. There is substantial evidence behind its core conditions. Empathy. And unconditional positive regard. The second is positive psychology. The humanistic movement helped inspire it. And positive psychology studies well-being with rigorous methods. The conclusion drawn from those two is carefully worded. On this view, humanistic ideas have been refined and partly validated. Rather than refuted.

The Test Case

Empathy and Genuineness

The strongest single piece of evidence is worth isolating. There is strong research support for therapist empathy. And for genuineness, in client-centered therapy. That is cited for a specific reason. It shows that the concepts are not all untestable. Despite the measurement challenges, some humanistic ideas can be tested and validated. And those particular ones were. But be clear about what that does and does not settle. The core conditions have survived testing. Self-actualization has not been through the same process. The defence is strongest exactly where the concepts got specific.

Consolidate

Critique and Response, Side by Side

Set the critiques and responses side by side. Concepts are hard to measure. The response is that subjective experience still matters. The approach is overly optimistic. The response is that it highlights neglected human strengths. It ignores the unconscious. The response is that it focuses on conscious meaning and choice. It is culturally narrow. The response is that it is adaptable to diverse contexts. And it has a weak empirical base. The response is that core therapy conditions are supported. Read that third row as a reframe rather than a rebuttal. It concedes the scope limit, and defends it as a deliberate choice. Which is a different kind of answer from the last row.

The Verdict

What the Two Questions Come To

Two questions to close on. Why is humanistic psychology criticised as hard to test? Because its central concepts resist precise definition, and precise measurement. And how do defenders respond? By arguing that meaning and experience matter, even when hard to quantify. And that key therapeutic conditions are empirically supported. Those two answers are not equal in strength, and it is worth saying so. The first is a claim about what psychology should value. The second is evidence.

About Psychology of Personality at UPI Study

Psychology of Personality (Psychology 300) is a self-paced online course of 83 video lessons in 13 chapters, from Freud, Adler and Jung to biological, behavioral, cognitive, existential and humanistic theories, traits, personality disorders and culture. It carries a NCCRS credit recommendation for 3 semester credits.

Every lesson transcript is free on pages like this one, and the videos are free with a free UPI Study account. Enrolling adds a practice quiz after each lesson, the graded work and final exam that earn the credit, lifetime access, and an official transcript on completion. UPI Study has helped over 130,000 students with college credits. ACE and NCCRS have over 2,100 cooperating colleges that will consider accepting credits; the final decision is with the universities.

Enroll now → Course details Download the syllabus All Psychology and social science courses Every course with PRO →

Compare: Abnormal Psychology vs Psychology of Personality

Why take it here

Why students take Psychology of Personality with UPI Study

What makes each person who they arePsychology of Personality compares the major explanations of why people differ: psychoanalytic and neo-analytic theories, biology and evolution, learning, cognition, existential and humanistic views, and trait models, plus how personality is measured and studied. It is a common course in psychology degrees.

Credit at a fraction of the priceThe same 3 credits can cost $750 or more at a US college. Here it is one payment, self-paced, with lifetime access.

Finish your degree soonerTransfer credits reduce the courses you still owe, so you can graduate earlier or lighten a heavy semester.

Strengthen an applicationA completed college-level course on an official transcript shows admissions and scholarship committees you can do the work.

Study on your own scheduleNo start dates, no deadlines. Watch the lessons, practice, and take the final when you are ready.

130,000+students helped with college creditsACE and NCCRS have over 2,100 cooperating colleges that will consider accepting credits; the final decision is with the universities.

Where the credit goes

Universities that work with NCCRS

Psychology of Personality carries a NCCRS credit recommendation. These universities work with NCCRS; some are UPI Study's signed partners. ACE and NCCRS have over 2,100 cooperating colleges that will consider accepting credits; the final decision is with the universities.

Thomas Edison State UniversitySigned partner

University of the PeopleSigned partner

Charter Oak State CollegeSigned partner

Strayer UniversitySigned partner

Columbia Southern UniversitySigned partner

Indiana TechSigned partner

Penn StateWorks with NCCRS

Southern New Hampshire UniversityWorks with NCCRS

SUNYWorks with NCCRS +many more cooperating universitiesFind my college →

Find my college → Not listed? Ask Athena in the corner of this page, or book a 15-minute call.

FAQ

Questions students ask us

About Critiques of Humanistic Psychology: Limitations and Counterarguments

What are the main criticisms of humanistic psychology?

The main criticisms of humanistic psychology are that its concepts are hard to measure, its view of human nature is overly optimistic, its emphasis on individual growth reflects particular cultural values, and its empirical base is weak. Critics say it pays too little attention to destructive behavior, situational pressures, and unconscious processes, and that it presents a culturally located ideal of self-direction as a universal truth about personality.

What is operationalization, and why is it a problem for humanistic psychology?

Operationalization means defining a concept in measurable terms so that evidence can bear on it. It is a problem for humanistic psychology because concepts such as self-actualization and the fully functioning person are difficult to define precisely and to measure objectively. Until a concept is operationalized, systematic testing is very difficult, which is why the approach scores high on attention to meaning but lower on empirical testability than trait models.

How do supporters defend humanistic psychology against claims it is unscientific?

Supporters offer two kinds of defense. The first argues that subjective experience matters even when it is hard to measure, and that strictly objective methods can miss what matters most about being human. That point is fair, but importance is not evidence that any specific claim is true. The second defense is stronger because it points to evidence, from research on client-centered therapy and from the rigorous methods of positive psychology.

Is there research evidence supporting humanistic psychology?

Yes, some humanistic ideas have solid research support, especially Carl Rogers' therapist conditions. Meta-analyses link therapist empathy to better outcomes, and genuineness and unconditional positive regard also show positive links, though with a smaller research base. This shows that not all humanistic concepts are untestable. Positive psychology, which the humanistic movement helped inspire, also studies well-being with rigorous methods. Self-actualization has not been validated in the same way, so humanistic ideas are best described as refined and partly validated.

About the Psychology of Personality course

How many college credits is Psychology of Personality?

Psychology of Personality (Psychology 300) carries a NCCRS credit recommendation for 3 semester credits. ACE and NCCRS have over 2,100 cooperating colleges that will consider accepting credits; the final decision is with the universities.

How much does Psychology of Personality cost and what is included?

$250, paid once, with lifetime access: all 83 video lessons, a practice quiz after each, the graded work and final exam, and an official transcript when you finish. Students who want several courses choose UPI Study PRO instead.

Which universities accept UPI Study credits?

UPI Study has signed partner agreements with universities such as Thomas Edison State University, University of the People and Charter Oak State College, and works with universities such as Penn State, SNHU and SUNY. ACE and NCCRS have over 2,100 cooperating colleges that will consider accepting credits; the final decision is with the universities. Use "Find my college" on this page to check yours.

How long does Psychology of Personality take?

It is self-paced with no deadlines. The 83 lessons total about 8 hours of video; most students add reading and practice time and finish in a few weeks to a few months, on their own schedule.

How are the exams done?

Quizzes and assignments are online in the course. The final exam is taken online with proctoring; a person on the UPI Study team checks assignments, usually within two days.

How do my credits reach my college?

When the course shows 100% complete, request the official transcript from your dashboard. It is sent to the college you name, and you can send it to more than one. Check your college first with "Find my college" on this page, or ask Athena.

Ready for the full course? Earn 3 credits in Psychology of Personality.

83 video lessons, a quiz after each one, and the graded work that earns the credit. Recommended for credit by NCCRS.

Enroll in Psychology of Personality →Download the syllabus Every course with PRO →

Psychology of Personality
3 credits · NCCRSEnroll →